222 sokong dari 91 menolak, mana lebih wibawa?

Pihak menyindir sokongan pemegang PhD tampil dengan berpihak kepada yang menolak

SEMALAM, 12 Januari 2021, bila seramai 222 pemegang ijazah PhD, 217 berbangsa Melayu dan 5 berbangsa bukan-Melayu, menyatakan sokongan terhadap Pengisytiharan Proklamasi Darurat sesetengah pihak begitu cepat sekali menyindir mereka.

Mereka mungkin terlupa bahawa bila seramai 91 ahli akademik, 39 berbangsa Melayu dan 52 berbangsa bukan-Melayu, menyatakan bantahan terhadap cadangan Pengisytiharan Proklamasi Darurat pada 25 Oktober 2020 pihak yang sama memuji mereka.

Advertisement

Sudah beginikah jadinya amalan demokrasi dan kebebasan bersuara di negara ini: Bila pihak yang mewakili majoriti rakyat dengan bilangan lebih besar bersuara maka ia tidak bagus tetapi bagus pula bila pihak yang mewakili minoriti rakyat yang bersuara?

Antara 91 ahli akademik yang sebahagiannya tidak mempunyai ijazah PhD pun, malah 8 daripadanya adalah pelajar PhD dan 2 daripadanya adalah pelajar MA sahaja, dengan 222 pemegang ijazah PhD mana yang lagi banyak dan berwibawa?

Bila suara 222 pemegang ijazah PhD, yang bilangannya semakin bertambah, adalah lagi banyak dan berwibawa, mengapa mereka perlu disindir oleh pihak itu sedangkan kami sendiri tidak pernah menyindir sewaktu 91 ahli akademik ini bersuara?

Senarai 39 ahli akademik berbangsa Melayu yang membantah cadangan darurat

1. Prof Emeritus Dato’ Dr Abdul Rahman Embong, retired academic
2. Dato’ Dr Ahmad Mahdzan Ayob, retired professor, former university deputy vice-chancellor
3. Dr Norani Othman, retired professor of sociology
4. Dr Omar Shawkataly, retired academic
5. Dr Wan Manan Wan Muda, retired academic
6. Dr Azizan Bahari, retired academic, writer
7. Mr Abdul Halim Ali, retired professor of sociology
8. Mr Rosli H. Mahat, retired associate professor of physics
9. Prof Emerita Dato Dr Wazir Jahan Karim, Anthropologist and Conservationist
10. Prof Emeritus Datuk Dr Muhamad Hj Salleh
11. Prof Dr Syed Farid Alatas, National University of Singapore
12. Prof Dato’ Dr Mohammad Agus Yusoff, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia
13. Prof Dr Mohamed Aslam Haneef, International Islamic University of Malaysia
14. Prof Dr Nor Faridah Abdul Manaf, International Islamic University Of Malaysia
15. Prof Zaharom Nain, University of Nottingham Malaysia
16. Dr Mohd Faizal Musa, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia
17. Dr Rusaslina Idrus, Universiti Malaya
18. Dr Mazlan Che Soh, Universiti Teknologi MARA (UiTM)
19. Dr Muhamad Azwan Abd Rahman, Universiti Utara Malaysia
20. Dr Tunku Mohar Tunku Mohd Mokhtar, International Islamic University of Malaysia
21. Dr Azmil Tayeb, Universiti Sains Malaysia
22. Dr Ramze Endut, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia
23. Dr Wan Puspa Melati Wan Abdul Halim, Academic
24. Dr Sharifah Munirah Alatas, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia
25. Dr Muhamad Nadzri Mohamed Noor, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia
26. Mr Muhammad Ariff Asyrul Adnan, Universiti Teknologi MARA (UiTM)
27. Mr Azmyl Yusof, Sunway University
28. Mr Akmal Hisham Abdul Rahim, Universiti Teknologi MARA (UiTM)
29. Mr Aznijar Mohd Yazid, Universiti Malaya
30. Ms Syahida Johan, Academic
31. Ms Aisyah Tajuddin, Academic
32. Ms Nabilah Huda, Academic
33. Mr Ab Bassit Husain, Academic, Universiti Kuala Lumpur & PhD Candidate
34. Mr Haris Zuan Jaharudin, Academic & PhD candidate, Cranfield University
35. Ms Fatimah Mohd Tajuddin, Academic & PhD candidate
36. Mr Zikri Rahman, PhD candidate, National Chiao Tung University
37. Mr Helmy Muhammad, PhD candidate
38. Mr Fairuzzaman Shaharuddin, PhD candidate
39. Mr Mohd Sazni, MA candidate

Senarai 52 ahli akademik berbangsa bukan-Melayu yang membantah cadangan darurat

1. Prof Emeritus Dr Tham Siew Yean, retired academic
2. Dr Ong Puay Liu, retired professor of anthropology
3. Dr Francis Loh Kok Wah, retired professor of politics
4. Dr Subramaniam Pillay, retired academic and co- founder of Aliran
5. Dr Madeline Berma, retired academic; Fellow, Academy of Sciences Malaysia
6. Dr Phua Kai Lit, retired associate professor
7. Dr Lim Teck Ghee, retired academic
8. Dr Andrew Aeria, retired academic
9. Dr Chan lean Heng, retired academic
10. Dr V. Selvaratnam, retired academic
11. Ms Marilyn Ong Siew Ai, retired academic
12. Mr Bealeatham Kalimuthu, retired academic
13. Prof Dr Maude E Phipps, Monash University Malaysia
14. Prof Dr Edmund Terence Gomez, Universiti Malaya
15. Prof Dr Sharmani Patricia Gabriel, Universiti Malaya
16. Prof Dr Teh Yik Koon, Universiti Pertahanan Nasional Malaysia
17. Prof Dr Chin Yee Whah, Universiti Sains Malaysia
18. Prof Madya Dr Helen Ting, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia
19. Prof Madya Dr Lew Bon Hoi, New Era University College
20. Prof Madya Dr Yeoh Seng Guan, Monash University Malaysia
21. Prof Madya Dr Kuik Cheng Chwee, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia
22. Prof Madya Dr Sumit Mandal, University of Nottingham Malaysia
23. Prof Madya Dr Khoo Gaik Cheng, University of Nottingham Malaysia
24. Prof Madya Dr Sivachandralingam Sundara Raja, Universiti Malaya
25. Prof Madya Dr Chang Yun Fah, Taylor’s University Malaysia
26. Dr Hew Wai Weng, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia
27. Dr Lai Suat Yan, Universiti Malaya
28. Dr Khoo Ying Hooi, Universiti Malaya
29. Dr Greg Lopez, Murdoch University
30. Dr Charis Quay Huei Li, Université Paris-Saclay
31. Dr Por Heong Hong, Universiti Sains Malaysia
32. Dr Chong Wu Ling, Universiti Malaya
33. Dr Ngo Sheau Shi, Universiti Sains Malaysia
34. Dr Yuwana Podin, Universiti Malaysia Sarawak
35. Dr Koh Sin Yee, Monash University Malaysia
36. Dr Brendan J. Gomez, Independent scholar
37. Dr Show Ying Xin, Australian National University
38. Dr Athi Sivan T. Mariappan, Independent researcher
39. Dr Wilson Tay Tze Vern, Taylor’s University Malaysia
40. Dr Lee Hwok Aun, ISEAS-Yusof Ishak Institute
41. Dr Chai Ming Hock, Universiti Sains Malaysia
42. Dr Simon Soon, Universiti Malaya
43. Dr Chang Teck Peng, Tunku Abdul Rahman University College
44. Dr Wong Kok Keong, Berjaya University College
45. Dr Welyne Jeffrey Jehom, Universiti Malaya
46. Dr Ngeow Chow Bing, Universiti Malaya
47. Dr Peter Chang, Universiti Malaya
48. Mr Teo Lee Ken, Independent researcher
49. Mr U K Menon, CEO, Espact Education
50. Ms Tricia Yeoh, PhD candidate, University of Nottingham Malaysia
51. Ms Fang Yi Xue, academic (INTI International University) & PhD Candidate
52. Mr Ooi Kok Hin, MA candidate, independent researcher

Senarai 217 ahli akademik berbangsa Melayu yang menyokong pengisytiharan darurat

1. Dr Ab Aziz Bin Yusof
2. Prof Ir Ts Dr Abd. Rahim Bin Abu Talib
3. Dr Abdul Aziz Bin Hussin
4. Dr Abdul Ghaffar Bin Surip
5. Dr Abdul Halim Bin Abdul Majid
6. Dr Abdul Jalil Bin Ali
7. Prof Madya Dr Abdul Karim Bin Ali
8. Prof Dr Abdul Muati @ Zamri Bin Ahmad
9. Dr Abdul Razif Bin Zaini
10. Dr Abdul Syukor Bin Mohamad Jaya
11. Dr Abdullah Sudin Bin Ab Rahman
12. Dr Abu Zaki Bin Ismail
13. Dr Achmad Dzariean Bin Mohd Nadzri
14. Prof Madya Dr Adi Yasran Bin Abdul Aziz
15. Prof Madya Ts Dr Adzhar Bin Kamaludin
16. Dr Ahmad Bin Yussuf
17. Dr Ahmad El-Muhammady Bin Muhammad Uthman El-Muhammady
18. Dr Ahmad Faisal Bin Abdul Hamid
19. Dr Ahmad Irdha Bin Mokhtar
20. Prof Madya Ts Dr Ahmad Naim Bin Ahmad Yahaya
21. Dr Ahmad Najib Bin Abdullah
22. Prof Ir Dr Ahmad Razlan Bin Yusoff
23. Prof Madya Dr Ahmad Shukri Bin Muhammad Noor
24. Dr Ainul Hakimah Binti Karim
25. Dr Alihanafiah Bin Norasid
26. Prof Madya Dr Amini Amir Bin Abdullah
27. Prof Madya Dr Aminurraasyid BinYatiban
28. Dr Amir Aatieff Bin Amir Hussin
29. Prof Datuk Dr Amir Hussin Bin Baharuddin
30. Dr Anang Hudaya Binti Muhamad Amin
31. Prof Madya Dr Anuar Shah Bin Bali Mahomed
32. Prof Madya Dr Arba’ie Bin Sujud
33. Dr Asyiqin Binti Ab Halim
34. Dr Azizah Binti Husin
35. Dr Azizi Bin Umar
36. Dr Azza Jauhar Binti Ahmad Tajuddin
37. Prof Emeritus Dr Barjoyai Bin Bardai
38. Prof Madya Dr Berhanuddin Bin Abdullah
39. Prof Madya Dr Che Hasniza Binti Che Noh
40. Prof Dr Che Husna Binti Azahari
41. Dr Che Mat Ali Bin Abd. Ghani
42. Dr Che Mohd Zaid Bin Yusof
43. Prof Madya Dr Dayang Maryama Binti Ag Daud
44. Prof Madya Dr Eris Elianddy Bin Supeni
45. Dr Faizuri Bin Abd Latif
46. Dr Fakhrorazi Bin Ahmad
47. Prof Madya Dr Fazli Bin Mohd
48. Dr Ghazali Bin Zainuddin
49. Dr Hailan Bin Salamun
50. Prof Ir Dr Hairul Azhar Bin Abdul Rashid
51. Dr Hanif Bin Md Lateh @ Junid
52. Dr Hasbullah Bin Mohamad
53. Prof Emeritus Tan Sri Dato’ Seri Dr Ibrahim Shah Bin Abu Shah
54. Prof Emeritus Dato’ Dr Isahak Bin Haron
55. Prof Dr Ishak Bin Saat
56. Dr Ismail Bin Ibrahim
57. Dr Kamarul Ariffin Bin Ithnan
58. Prof Madya Dr Kamarul Ariffin Bin Noordin
59. Dr Kamarul Azman Bin Khamis
60. Dr Kamarul Zaman Bin Haji Yusoff
61. Prof Madya Dr Kamarulzaman Bin Abdul Ghani
62. Prof Madya Dr Kamaruzaman Bin Noordin
63. Prof Dr Kamaruzzaman Bin Yusof
64. Prof Datuk Dr Kasim Bin Hj Md Mansur
65. Dr Khadher Bin Ahmad
66. Dr Khairuddin Bin Md Isa
67. Prof Dr Khairuddin Bin Omar
68. Dr Linamalini Binti Mat Nafi
69. Dr Lokmal Hakim Bin Che Hassan
70. Dr Mansor Bin Ahmad
71. Prof Dr Mansor Bin Mohd Noor
72. Prof Madya Dr Mansor Bin Sulaiman
73. Dr Mashitah Binti Mohd Udin
74. Dr Mas Juliana Binti Mukhtaruddin
75. Prof Dr Masran Bin Saruwono
76. Ar Dr Mastor Bin Surat
77. Prof Madya Dr Mazlan Bin Ibrahim
78. Prof Madya Dr Mohad Anizu Bin Mohd Nor
79. Prof Madya Dr Mohamad Amran Bin Mohd Salleh
80. Prof Madya Dr Mohamad Faisol Bin Keling
81. Dr Mohamad Ghozali Bin Hasan
82. Dr Mohamad Hilmie Bin Mat Daud
83. Dr Mohamad Saleeh Rahamad
84. Ir Dr Mohammad Effendy Bin Yaacob
85. Dr Mohammad Tawfik Bin Yaakub
86. Dr Mohd Adnin Bin Hamidi
87. Prof Madya Dr Mohd Afandi Bin Mat Rani
88. Dr Mohd Al’ikhsan Bin Ghazali
89. Dr Mohd Alwee Bin Yusoff
90. Dr Mohd Ashrof Zaki Bin Yaakob
91. Dr Mohd Asri Bin Che Ibrahim
92. Dr Mohd Azhar Bin Abdullah
93. Dr Mohd Bakhit Bin Haji Ali
94. Prof Madya Dr Mohd Dzulkhairi Bin Mohd Rani
95. Dr Mohd Faisal Bin Abdul Khanan
96. Prof Madya Dr Mohd Fauzi Bin Hamat
97. Dr Mohd Fuad Bin Mohd Salleh
98. Dr Mohd Hafiz Bin Jamaluddin
99. Prof Madya Dr Mohd Hanif Bin Yaacob
100. Dr Mohd Hapiz Bin Mahaiyadin
101. Dr Mohd Hazri Bin Mohd Rusli
102. Dr Ts Ir Mohd Hilmi Bin Othman
103. Prof Dr Mohd Kamarulnizam Bin Abdullah
104. Prof Madya Dr Mohd Mahadee Bin Ismail
105. Prof Madya Dr Dr Mohd Mizan Bin Aslam
106. Prof Madya Dr Mohd Muhiden Bin Abd Rahman
107. Prof Madya Dr Mohd Nazir Bin Md Zabit
108. Prof Madya Dr Mohd Nazree Bin Derman
109. Prof Madya Dr Mohd. Noor Bin Mat Yazid
110. Dr Mohd Nor Bin Husin
111. Dr Mohd Norhusairi Bin Mat Hussin
112. Prof Dato’ Ir Ts Dr Mohd Rizon Bin Mohamed Juhari
113. Dr Mohd Roshdi Bin Hassan
114. Datuk Dr Mohd Noh Bin Dalimin @ Dolimin
115. Ir Dr Mohd Norshahrani Bin Abdul Rahim
116. Prof Madya Dr Mohd Nuri Al Amin Bin Endut
117. Dr Mohd Ramizu Bin Abdullah @ Zakaria
118. Prof Dr Mohd Roslan Bin Mohd Nor
119. Dr Mohd Syakir Bin Mohd Rosdi
120. Ts Dr Mohd Zafran Bin Abdul Aziz
121. Prof Madya Dr Mohd Zahuri Bin Khairani
122. Dr Mohd Zaidi Bin Daud
123. Kol Prof Madya DrMohd Zaini Bin Salleh (B)
124. Prof Madya Dr Mohd Zaki Bin Hamzah
125. Dr Mohd. Faizal Bin P. Rameli
126. Prof Dr Mohd. Sahandri Gani Bin Hamzah
127. Dr Muhamad Zuhairi Bin Sulaiman
128. Prof Madya Datuk Dr Muhammad Bin Hussin
129. Prof Madya Dr Muhammad Bin Ibrahim
130. Dr Muhammad Azrul Bin Zabidi
131. Dr Muhammad Ikhlas Bin Rosele
132. Dr Muhammad Khair Bin Noordin
133. Dr Muhammad Rusdi Bin Ab. Majid
134. Prof Madya Dr Muhammad Saiful Haq Bin Hussin.
135. Prof Madya Dr Muhammad Sharfi Bin Najib
136. Dr Muhd Imran Bin Abd Razak
137. Dr Muhd Fauzi Bin Mohd Jani
138. Prof Madya Dr Mus Chairil Bin Samani
139. Dr Mustafa Bin Ahmad
140. Prof Madya Dr Mustaffa Bin Abdullah
141. Dr Najahudin Bin Lateh
142. Dr Nasrul Hadi Bin Johari
143. Prof Madya Ir Dr Nawal Aswan Bin Abdul Jalil
144. Prof Madya Dr Nazarudin Bin Zainun
145. Dr Nik Mawardi Bin Mohamed
146. Dr Nik Md Saiful Azizi Bin Nik Abdullah
147. Dr Nik Noorkhairulnissa Binti Nik Hassan
148. Prof Madya Dr Nik Yusri Bin Musa
149. Dr Nizar Bin Abd Manan
150. Dr Noor Azli Bin Muhamed Masrop
151. Prof Ts Dr Noor Maizura Binti Mohamad Noor
152. Dr Noorhaslinda Binti Kulub Abd Rashid
153. Dr Nor Azian Binti Hj Ab Rahman
154. Prof Madya Dr Nor Hafizi Bin Yusof
155. Dr Nor Hazrul Bin Mohd Salleh
156. Dr Norazuwana Binti Shaari
157. Prof Madya Dr Nordin Bin Jamaludin
158. Dr Nordin Bin Sakke
159. Dr Norfazila Binti Abdul Hamid
160. Prof Madya Dr Nur Nafhatun Binti Md Shariff
161. Dr Nurul Akma Binti Mohamed
162. Prof Madya Dr Omrah Bin Hassan @ Hussin
163. Prof Madya Dr Rahimah Binti Embong
164. Dr Rahimi Binti Abidin
165. Dr Rafidah Binti Azli
166. Dr Rafidah Binti Hasan
167. Dr Raja Hisyamudin Bin Raja Sulong
168. Dr Raja Jamilah Raja Yusof
169. Prof Madya Dr Ratnaria Binti Wahid
170. Dr Razali Bin Muda
171. Dr Rofishah Binti Rashid
172. Prof Madya Dr Rohani Binti Abdul Ghani
173. Dr Rohayu Binti Maaru
174. Dr Rosfazila Binti Hj. Abd Rahman
175. Prof Madya Dr Rusdi Bin Omar
176. Dr Saifulah Bin Samsudin
177. Prof Dr Sakri Bin Ibrahim
178. Dr Salman Bin Zainal Abidin.
179. Dr Samsudin Bin Wahab
180. Dr Salmah Binti Karman
181. Prof Madya Dr Saupi Bin Man
182. Dr Shahrudin Bin Awang Nor
183. Prof Dr Shamrahayu Binti Ab Aziz
184. Dr Shazli Ezzat Bin Ghazali
185. Dato’ Prof Dr Sheikh Hussin Bin Ab Rahman Al Amudi
186. Prof Madya Dr Shukeri Bin Mohamad
187. Dr Siti Aisyah Binti Samudin
188. Dr Suharmili Binti Rosle
189. Prof Emeritus Datuk Dr Sukiman Bin Sarmani
190. Dr Suzilawati Binti Muhamud
191. Dr Syarbaini Bin Ahmad
192. Ts Dr Syed Agil Bin Shekh Alsagoff
193. Dr Tengku Putri Norishah Binti Tengku Shahriman
194. Dr Tuan Mohd Sapuan Bin Tuan Ismail
195. Dr Tuan Sidek Bin Tuan Muda
196. Prof Madya Dr Uswatun Hasanah Binti Zaidan
197. Dr Uzaimah Binti Ibrahim
198. Prof Madya Datuk Dr Wan Ahmad Fauzi Bin Hashim @ Wan Husain
199. Prof Emeritus Dato’ Dr Wan Hashim Bin Wan Teh
200. Prof Madya Dr Wan Iryani Binti Wan Ismail
201. Dr Wan Mat Bin Sulaiman
202. Dr Wan Mohd Yusof Bin Wan Chik
203. Prof Dr Wan Mohtar Bin Wan Yusoff
204. Dr Wan Nasyrudin Bin Wan Abdullah
205. Dr Wan Rohani Binti Wan Mokhtar
206. Prof Madya Dr Wan Zailan Kamaruddin Bin Wan Ali
207. Dr Yusni Zaini Binti Yusoff
208. Dr Zahrul Akmal Bin Haji Damin
209. Dr Zaidi Bin Abdul Rahman
210. Dr Zainuddin Bin Omar
211. Prof Dr Zainur Rashid Bin Zainuddin
212. Prof Emeritus Datuk Dr Zakariah Bin Abdul Rashid
213. Prof Dr Zulfadzli Bin Yusoff
214. Prof Dato’ Dr Zulkifli Bin Haji Mohd Yusoff
215. Dr Zulfirdaus Bin Zakaria
216. Dr Zuraidah Binti Zan
217. Prof Madya Dr Zuraini Binti Mat Issa

Senarai 5 ahli akademik berbangsa bukan-Melayu yang menyokong pengisytiharan darurat

1. Dr Hoo Kee Ping
2. Dr Iskandar Hasan Tan Bin Abdullah
3. Dr Low Yong San
4. Prof Dr Mohd Ridhuan Tee Bin Abdullah
5. Prof Madya Dr R Sivaperegasam P Rajanthiran 

DR KAMARUL ZAMAN HAJI YUSOFF – HARAKAHDAILY 13/1/2021

PENAFIAN:
HarakahDaily tidak bertanggungjawab terhadap pandangan yang dikemukakan daripada artikel ini. Ia pandangan peribadi penulis dan tidak semestinya menggambarkan pendirian HarakahDaily mahupun pendirian rasmi PAS. Segala risiko akibat penyiaran ini menjadi tanggungjawab penulis sendiri.